From our earliest days we Americans have yearned for tax relief. Benjamin Franklin (1706-1790) is widely believed to claim that the only things we can’t avoid are death and taxes.
As a hospice chaplain I tell you how hard we try to avoid both. I’m not normally a fan of the “good old days” but there was a time when many Americans saw paying taxes as a form of patriotism. You can see a funny Donald Duck video from 1943 that tied taxes into support for World War II.
But the IRS 1040 form from 1943 was only 4 pages long. In fairness, the 1040 from 2016 is only 2 pages long, but the instruction book for the 1040 is 106 pages long. Clearly paying taxes has become much more complicated.
Republicans promise to reduce our tax returns to a postcard. But here’s the thing: it’s already easy if you don’t care how much you pay. Filing taxes requires to do two things: finding the difference between gross income and taxable income, and finding out how much we owe based on our taxable income.
Most of us (myself included) hire someone to do our taxes (and if you live in San Diego I strongly recommend Mark Young). But we need to hire someone to find the difference between gross income and taxable income. We can deduct from our gross income the money we spend on charitable donations, interest on home loans, and countless other things. Simply put, the government uses deductions to encourage certain behaviors. The government wants us to donate money, purchase homes, etc, and they encourage us to do these things by giving us a tax break.
But if you don’t care about this, all you need to do is declare your gross income as your taxable income. If you do this, all you need to do is look on a simple table to see how much you owe and pay it. This would take less than a minute.
And when politicians promise to “close loopholes” they are promising to eliminate deductions and make your gross income closer to your taxable income. But every loophole has a lobbyist whose salary depends on keeping that same deduction. Do you want to eliminate the home mortgage interest deduction? Good luck. You’ve declared war on the National Association of Realtors. Do you happily donate money to your local charity? Good luck. Expect pushback from your church, the Salvation Army, the Red Cross, the San Diego Blood Bank, and well, you get the point.
In fairness President Trump has promised to keep deductions for mortgage interest rates and charities. But look over your last tax return and see how many deductions you were able to take. If the only difference between your gross income and taxable income came from these two places, how much more is there? Are you willing to lose those deductions?
I don’t think so and I don’t think President Trump can pull this off.
There’s much more to this and I’ll be writing more. Stay tuned.